Thoughts on the Sony RX1

The interwebs are abuzz with rumour and speculation, one of the most unexpected being that of the Sony RX1 fixed lens large sensor compact camera (Photos from Sony Alpha Rumors).

The rumoured headline specifications are a 36mm x 24mm CMOS sensor (probably 24MP), 35mm/2 Zeiss Sonnar lens, and a price of $2799. We’ll find out whether these are true in a few days but I’d like to comment on the reaction around the web to these (alleged) details.

Common laments:

  • It’s too expensive
  • It’s a fixed lens
  • It’s not pocketable
  • It doesn’t have a OVF or EVF

It’s perfectly reasonable to express how it does or does not fit within your own circumstances or shooting style, but then some proceed to project their own feelings and requirements onto everyone else and declare the camera an “epic fail” or similar. Just because it isn’t appropriate for your use doesn’t mean it won’t be entirely fitting for someone else.

“It’s too expensive!” If the rumoured price is correct, then it certainly won’t be a cheap camera. The question whether it is too expensive is solely a function of the market. Consider the premium which Leica cameras command. An M9P is £5200 body only, to which you can add an extra £2100 for a 35mm/2 lens. The Leica X2 (APS-C sensor, 24mm/2.8 lens) is £1500 which makes it marginally cheaper than the RX1. If you are the market for a Leica X2, then the RX1 will be a strong contender (unless you must have the red dot on your camera).

“It’s a fixed lens” A 35mm/2 lens is a good choice for general purpose candid/street photography. Many notable street photographers would happily shoot with just a 35mm lens on a Leica. If you live and breathe street photography, this camera could be just your tool of choice. It may not be your only camera, but it could easily serve as a great travel camera, street/candid camera, or backup camera.

“It’s not pocketable” Depends on how big your pockets are. It’s not going to replace your phone camera, it won’t replace a small compact digicam, but it could replace having to carry a DSLR or a Leica M9 when shooting discretely. From what can be discerned from the photos, it should fit in a coat pocket easily, something you cannot say about a 5DIII or D700.

“It doesn’t have an OVF/EVF” Further rumour has it that external OVF/EVFs will be available. For a fixed 35mm lens, an external OVF would be fine for quick candids and street photos. Having used both a NEX-5 and NEX-7, the built-in EVF of the NEX-7 is more convenient but I was still able to use the NEX-5 without too much trouble. Having the option of an external EVF should assuage the doubts for most people.

The main problem is evaluating such a niche market camera by criteria which don’t represent the niche it is aiming towards. It is nonsensical to evaluate the people-carrying capability of a Caterham 7, just as the quater-mile time of a Nissin Micra is mostly irrelevant. The RX1 is not an NEX camera, it is not meant to fulfil the general needs that an interchangeable camera can fill. You are not going to be shooting sports, classic portraits, go birding, or make ultra-wide angle shots with this camera. However, if you need a small and discreet camera with a large sensor and moderately wide prime with (presumably) superb image quality and tactile feel, the RX1 should be high on your list.

Personally, I can’t see myself getting the RX1 even if it were much cheaper. Even though street and candid photography are a major photographic interest, I don’t earn enough from it to justify getting a single camera for this purpose. Should I win the lottery, then I would considert the RX1 as a luxury item to enjoy shooting with. Instead, I look forward to the NEX-6 and the 35mm/1.8 OSS E-mount lens as a street/candid combo.

Samyang 8mm/2.8 on the NEX-7

CornerFix requires a reference shot in order to calculate a lens profile. This should be an shot of an evenly lit neutral surface. For a fisheye lens, this proves problematic as you cannot simply point it at a neutral grey card or white wall. I set up two flashes either side of the camera. I held up a white diffusion sheet so that it wrapped around the lens and gave full coverage over the angle of view (180 degrees diagonal). I then took several shots making sure that the image was not overexposed (no clipping).
Magenta lens cast in the corners due to oblique rays causing non-uniform response
CornerFix is able to compensate for the non-uniform response and reduce the colour casts

I just received my copy of the Samyang 8mm/2.8 fisheye in native NEX mount. I’ve tried it on the NEX-7 and have some very preliminary remarks. First the good news, it’s sharp, light, compact, pretty well made, and matches the form factor of the NEX-7 quite well. The only downside so far is the interaction of the lens with the sensor leading to magenta corners.

This lens colour cast is due to the way that off axis light rays interact with the filter stack on top of the sensor and the pixels themselves. The different coloured sites in the Bayer array are affected differently leading to colour casts. This can be a problem with certain lens designs where the exit pupil is situated close to the sensor (non-telecentricity).

To fix this, you can use CornerFix, a program which takes DNG files and applies a rescaling to the data to compensate for the lens colour cast. One has to first create a reference file from which the compensation can be calculated, not exactly straight forward for a 180 degree diagonal fisheye. I have made such a correction profile and people can download the file (you may need to right mouse click and choose “save link as”, or similar). The lens was set at f/5.6 but the profile should work more or less at other apertures. The correction isn’t perfect, but for most photographic scenery it corrects the majority of the colour cast, as well as the vignetting (which can be adjusted).

Sunday Times Licences Pano

Silver Birch Grove, Anglesey Abbey

I’ve been contributing to 360Cities.net for many years and have over 150 panorama hosted there. They are all available for licencing and today I was pleasantly surprised to find out that my panorama of the silver birch grove at Anglesey Abbey has been licensed by the Sunday Times for their iPad edition. The royalty cheque won’t make me rich by any means but it is nice to have my work picked up by a national paper.

Fontaine Saint-Michel

I’ve been going over my back catalogue of unstitched panoramas. These are mostly one which I didn’t have time to assemble at the time, or were lesser priority than other ones. However, this one was challenging to stitch due to the combination of lots of moving objects and the need to take a bracketed exposure for the sky, and I have waited nearly three years before attempting it. My post-process has improved and the tools I use have also advanced which means that I can now more easily assemble difficult panoramas.

The panorama was taken on a visit to Paris in July 2009. It was a lovely summer’s day, sunny but not too hot. The sunset was not going to be too spectacular so I decided to wander around to soak up the ambiance. The Fontaine Saint-Michel is a noted meeting spot for young and old. It had a lively atmosphere so I hung around and set up my tripod. The people near me didn’t seem to have a problem with it so I quickly took a series of shots, especially trying to capture the moving people and allow me latitude during assembly.

I knew at the time that it would be tricky to blend together the shots without cutting people in half. I had many other panoramas to stitch from the trip and I concentrated on the low lying fruit. Waiting three years to attempt this has paid dividends. The masking tools in Hugin and the RAW development in Lightroom 4 have improved immensely. With lots of masking, I was able to assemble a near seamless panorama, and the highlight recovery tool was able to bring down the highlights which helped blend bracketed exposures. Enfuse was then used to exposure fuse three renderings of the scene to adaptively compress the dynamic range into something which looks naturalistic.

I was able to assemble all the elements within Hugin itself without the need to use Photoshop to blend layers, clone or mask elements after stitching. I did my usual post-processing in Picture Windows Pro 6, levels, curves, large-radius sharpening, detail sharpening, and a few colour tweaks.

Singapore Marina Bay

I’m slowly going through photos which I took during a recent visit to Singapore. The Marina Bay area is quite colourful at night when the CBD and the new casino development are lit up. Night panoramas can be quite challenging, especially when coupled with lots of people moving around. The hot conditions also increases the dark current of digital sensors meaning that dark frame subtraction is a must on long exposures. It can take several minutes, maybe half an hour to get the photos for a single pano depending on how many shots are required to avoid people being cut in half.

The Merlion is an icon of Singapore, the one on Marina Bay shooting a geyser of water from its mouth a crowded tourist sport. This pano also surveys the bay with Marina Bay Sands Hotel and Casino opposite. Tourists and locals soak up the balmy evening air.

Panorama of Chester Cathedral

I have just returned from a weekend in Chester, an old walled town dating from Roman times. The cathedral is a beautiful building, especially the tiles on the floor and the vaulted ceiling.

I took a panorama of the Strathclyde University Chamber Choir rehearsing for Evensong. To obtain the image on the left, I remapped the spherical panorama, which was in equirectangular format, to a stereographic projection.  The tiled patterns form interesting geometric shapes.

Outdoor Model Shoot

A funny thing happened on the way to the shoot. Apparently, you have to get a certificate of permission to do any sort of model shoot in the Necropolis. I was informed by the groundsman and after some discussion, I was eventually let off for this time only and allowed to continue as long as I didn’t have any recognisable writings on headstones or monuments in the shots. I actually wanted to take advantage of the view and backdrop so in the end it wasn’t a big deal but I have had a lot of trouble finding out exactly who to contact should I want to do a future shoot in the Necropolis so any hints appreciated.

Anyway, the afternoon was bright though hazy. The sun was shining down but veiled with a thin layer of cloud. I still needed to bring down the ambient exposure by using an ND4 and used ISO50, 1/250th, and around f/4 to f/5.6 depending on the exact flash output and balance against daylight.

I placed the flash against the sun to allow the ambient light to partially fill in the shadows. I also used a reflector on a stand and arm to bounce the flash onto the back of the model. I used the sunfire surface to add some warmth and to match the sun.

I used a Bowens Gemini 400 flash powered by a Travelpak and the small battery. This gave around 300 shots at about half to three-quarter power on average. I mounted an octobox with both diffusers (probably could have gotten away with just the outer panel). I tried to place the flash as close as I could to the model to get a soft light, though at the cost of less even illumination. A strip light could have been a better choice had I had one.

I shot with the 16-50mm/2.8 and a Cokin P filter holder. This combination does vignette at the wide end so I had to either zoom in a bit or crop in the post-production to get rid of the mechanical vignetting. To be perverse, I added in artificial vignetting to accentuate the tunnel effect.

After the flash had finally run out of juice, it was time to do some available light portraits. The lay of cloud had thickened up a bit and though still partially sunny, the light was soft. I retreated to the shade to get an even more diffuse light.

I didn’t need the ND4 so I could take off the Cokin filter holder. I switched to the Tamron 70-200mm/2.8 so I could back up a bit and zoom in from a farther perspective. I positioned the model a bit away from the background so I could blur it out. In post-production, I added a bit of contrast and highlight adjustment to make the model separate from the background even more.

It was very handy to have a helping hand with the equipment. Even though the Bowens kit is “portable”, it’s not something you want to have to lug with you for very far. Together with all the extra bits and bobs (octobox, reflector, stands etc.), any help is appreciated.

Thanks to Sarah for modelling and to Francis for assisting despite a bad leg.

Story of a Picture

Here’s a pano which I took in France. I was visiting the town of Longny au Perche in Normandy and came across this artist in the grounds of the La chapelle Notre–Dame de Pitié, supposedly Mary Queen of Scots was responsible for its construction. The interior of the chapel can be seen here.

I was wandering around the ground when I saw the painter capturing the scene. In very broken French I managed to convey that I wanted to take her photo and would she mind. I detected no great objection so I set up  my camera close by and took this pano. Afterwards, I asked for her card and I sent a copy of the finished version.

This is my favourite projection of the pano, Miller cylindrical with a bit cropped off the top and bottom. The shadow of the is camera ominous opposite the sight of a traditional artist at work, the new and old facing off in this picturesque setting. I have to go back to the original source images and redo the pano, get rid of some stitching errors where the wind has blown the parasol around, and deal with flare in the sky. But I have a soft spot for this pano despite its technical flaws.

Panorama Photography Classes

I’m now offering one day classes in panoramic photography. It will cover the basic principles of panoramas, how to take the source imagery, align, assemble, and output the results. By the end of the day, you should be able to produce 360 degree cylindrical panorama or perhaps even a spherical panorama.

For those who already have the basics, I also offer personal tuition covering advanced techniques for overcoming difficult scenes, post-processing/remapping, and constructing VR tours.

Landscape and Panoramic Specialist in Glasgow