I recently received a Brightin Star 11mm/2.8 II in E mount. Here are some example shots on a Sony A7Rm3A (42MP) at ISO100, mounted on a tripod and with a remote release. I shot some comparison photos with the 7Artisans 10mm/2.8 II, its aperture range goes from f/2.8 to f/16, whereas the Brightin Star lens goes from f/2.8 to f/22. This is not a proper review of the Brightin Star lens but I hope the information will be useful to people considering this lens for panoramic photography.
The light during the day was fairly constant during each series of shots. Focus was manually adjusted using magnified live-view. The raw files were imported into Lightroom Classic 15.3 (Camera Raw 18.3), white balance was either shade or daylight, no other adjustments were made (no CA or vignetting). There were people in some of the shots who have been erased so this may have resulted in some artifacts which you should ignore. The shots were exported as JPG at full resolution and 100 quality.
Sharpness and Vignetting vs Aperture

































7Artisans Far Field Centre Focus, Aperture Series f/2.8, 4, 5.6, 8, 11, 16 (People Removed in Lightroom)






Flare Handling











Observations
The field of view (FoV) of the Brightin Star is considerably smaller than the 7Artisans. The claimed diagonal FoV of the Bright Star lens is 182 deg, however when measured directly or from a full panorama, it is in the region of ~167 deg.

The optimised lens parameters, derived from a full spherical panorama assembled in Hugin results in the above coverage. The horizontal & vertical FoVs are ~102 deg and ~144 deg respectively in portrait orientation. This does allow a shooting pattern of 4 shots at 90 degrees horizontal spacing plus Zenith and Nadir shots (4+Z+N). On the A7Rm3A, this results in an equirectangular panorama of approximately 18000 x 9000 pixels. Example below as an equirectangular, also viewable on Kuula.

The source photos and a Hugin project file can be downloaded here released under the Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 licence. The JPG files were exported from Lightroom from the raw files. Exposure and shadow recovery, black levels, and CA correction were applied.
The vignetting of the Brightin Star wide open is quite strong. Not apparent in the outside shots, but noticeable on interior shots with white walls is a cyan colour cast in the corners.
Concluding Remarks
The build of the Brightin Star is metal, solid and dense. The clickless aperture and focus rings are well damped. The sharpness is fine. However, I do not feel it provides anything over the Samyang 12mm/2.8 or the 7Artisans 10mm/2.8 II, except the lower price. The vignetting is worse than the 7Artisans and Samyang lenses, and the colour cast will require a lens profile to remove.
The FoV does allow a 4+Z+N shooting pattern, providing a similar final panorama size as the Samyang lens, but it is a touch tighter (the Samyang has a horizontal FoV of 106 deg) which gives less flexibility in choosing control points in the overlap region. The 7Artisans lens has a horizontal FoV of ~114 deg (~185 deg diagonal) which makes it even more comfortable shooting 4+Z+N than the Samyang, though with a slightly reduced final panorama size of 17000 x 8500 pixels.
I will continue to use the 7Artisans 10mm/2.8 II lens for my panoramas. The colour cast in the corners of the Brightin Star lens may be due to an interaction with the sensor stack on the A7Rm3A so it may not be a problem on other cameras, but this will need to be confirmed. The smaller than claimed FoV is disappointing, however. I have reached out to the company to query this, but without a response after several weeks yet. But for now, the Brightin Star 11mm/2.8 II will be left on the shelf.
Notes
All information provided without guarantee or warranty. I bought the Brightin Star 11mm/2.8 II at retail price, and as for all other equipment mentioned. This post is not sponsored and represents my own opinion. My impressions of the 7Artisans lens can be found here.
